Easy Homemade Butter Chicken

This hearty butter chicken has been my culinary lifeline during busy weeknights when I crave something comforting yet impressive. The rich, velvety sauce envelops tender chunks of chicken in a symphony of aromatic spices that transport you straight to an authentic Indian restaurant, all from the comfort of your kitchen.

I discovered this butter chicken recipe during a snowy weekend when takeout wasn't an option. What began as kitchen experimentation has become my most requested dish at family gatherings, with even my spice-hesitant relatives asking for seconds.

Ingredients

• Chicken thighs rather than breast meat provides juicier results that stay tender even when reheated
• Greek yogurt in the marinade tenderizes the chicken while adding subtle tanginess
• Garam masala brings authentic Indian flavor with its blend of cinnamon, cardamom and cloves
• Heavy cream creates that signature silky texture that defines butter chicken
• Tomato sauce provides the perfect base without requiring you to blend fresh tomatoes
• Real butter added at the end creates an irresistible richness that gives the dish its name

Step-by-Step Instructions

Marinate the Chicken

Combine chicken pieces with yogurt and spices, ensuring every piece gets coated evenly. This step creates the foundation of flavor. Allow at least 15 minutes for the marinade to work its magic on the proteins, though longer marination will yield even more tender results.

Sear the Chicken

Cook the marinated chicken in hot oil until golden on all sides. Look for slight caramelization at the edges which develops deeper flavor compounds. Avoid overcrowding the pan which prevents proper browning. The chicken doesnt need to be fully cooked through at this stage.

Create the Aromatic Base

Sauté onions and garlic in butter until translucent and fragrant. This aromatic foundation infuses the entire dish with depth. Take your time here approximately 5 minutes as rushing this step will result in less developed flavors.

Develop the Sauce

Introduce tomato sauce and spices, allowing them to simmer and concentrate. Watch as the oils begin to separate slightly from the sauce a sign the flavors are developing properly. This stage builds the complex base before adding cream.

Enrich with Cream

Pour in heavy cream gradually while stirring continuously to prevent splitting. The sauce will transform before your eyes from bright red to a gorgeous sunset orange. Maintain gentle heat to preserve the creamy texture.

Final Butter Finish

Melt remaining butter into the hot sauce just before serving. This finishing touch creates a glossy sheen and adds that signature richness that makes butter chicken irresistible. The fresh butter creates layers of flavor that cant be achieved by cooking all the butter at once.

Bookmark

The garam masala is truly the heart of this recipe. I remember the first time I made this for my mother in law who claimed to dislike Indian food she ended up asking for the recipe before dinner was even finished. Its the warming spices that create that magical aroma that fills your kitchen and makes everyone ask whats for dinner.

Finding the Perfect Balance

The beauty of homemade butter chicken lies in customizing the spice level to your preference. For those who enjoy heat, increase the cayenne pepper gradually until you reach your desired level. For family meals with children, you can omit it entirely and serve hot sauce on the side for adults. The dish maintains its character either way through the complex spice blend.

Making it Ahead

Butter chicken actually improves with time as the flavors meld together. You can prepare the entire dish up to three days before serving and refrigerate it in an airtight container. When reheating, do so gently over low heat with occasional stirring. Add a splash of cream if the sauce has thickened too much during storage. This make ahead capability makes it perfect for entertaining.

Serving Traditions

While rice and naan are traditional accompaniments, butter chicken pairs wonderfully with many sides. Try serving it with cauliflower rice for a lower carb option, or alongside roasted vegetables for a complete meal. For an authentic experience, prepare a simple cucumber raita on the side the cooling yogurt provides the perfect contrast to the rich sauce. I like to serve small dishes of additional garnishes like chopped cilantro, sliced almonds, and a squeeze of fresh lime to elevate the presentation.

Ingredient Flexibility

This recipe demonstrates remarkable adaptability to different dietary needs. Coconut cream makes an excellent substitute for heavy cream if youre avoiding dairy just omit the final butter addition or use a plant based alternative. For a leaner version, boneless skinless chicken breast works well if you reduce the cooking time slightly to prevent dryness. Vegetarians can replace the chicken with firm tofu or paneer cheese for an equally satisfying meal.

Bookmark

Recipe FAQs

→ What cut of chicken works best for butter chicken?

Boneless, skinless chicken thighs are ideal for butter chicken as they stay tender and juicy during cooking. Their slightly higher fat content contributes to the rich flavor. You could substitute chicken breast if preferred, but reduce the cooking time slightly to prevent it from becoming dry.

→ Can I make butter chicken ahead of time?

Yes! Butter chicken actually improves with time as the flavors meld together. You can prepare it up to 3 days ahead and store in the refrigerator. Reheat gently on the stovetop with a splash of cream or water if needed. The dish also freezes well for up to 2 months.

→ What can I substitute for heavy cream?

For a lighter version, you can substitute half-and-half or a mixture of whole milk and Greek yogurt. For a dairy-free alternative, full-fat coconut milk works beautifully and complements the spices well. Just be careful not to boil the sauce vigorously after adding any dairy to prevent curdling.

→ How spicy is this butter chicken?

This version is mildly spiced with warm flavors rather than heat. The optional cayenne pepper adds a gentle kick - add more if you prefer it spicier, or omit completely for a very mild dish. You can also add a dollop of yogurt when serving to cool it down further.

→ What's the difference between butter chicken and tikka masala?

While similar, butter chicken is generally creamier and milder, with a distinctly buttery finish. Tikka masala typically has a more complex, tangier tomato base with more pronounced spices. Butter chicken originated in Delhi, while tikka masala is thought to have British-Indian roots. Both are delicious tomato-based curry dishes!

→ Can I use store-bought garam masala?

Absolutely! Store-bought garam masala works perfectly in this recipe. For the freshest flavor, check the expiration date and consider buying from stores with high turnover of spices. If you have time, toasting store-bought garam masala in a dry pan for 30 seconds can help revive its aromatic qualities.